Smidly's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Choose Your Character!]

Pretty Awesome

I like the Pez ghosts. Also is that you at the bottom left?

Catoblepas responds:

a part of me what

[Luis Day!!!]

Sorta bad

In general I guess it's ok but she just looks weird. For example her arms are blocky and bulge in odd places. The thighs are WAY too big and the anime face doesn't fit with the rest of the body.

LegolaSS responds:

true... its a shit picture... iv learned from my mistakes here...

[No thanks, I'll just have this]

YOU SAYIN

BLACKS EAT WHITES? YOU A RACST!

Good work.

Rooshie responds:

No haha, I was to lazy to change his color. He was supposed to be a Mediterranean, some greek or italian dude.

[Robot Brawl]

I can't tell what's going on

It looks pretty but...what's going on.

Osuka responds:

The Mindchamebr robot is punching the Hamal Robot in the face, but is too confusing the image. Maybe I dont see that because I know my robot, the next time i will make another composition that would be easy to see what going on
thanks

[fleec]

Sort of bad

I don't really think that the art portal needs two frame MSN Icons but whatever. The things is a bit simple, and the anime face makes me nerd rage abit. The shading is nice though.

Polonium responds:

lmao I hate anime and so does fleek

I just like to tease him

honestly I made this in paint and compiled the frames in gickr.com which sounds primitive and is, but it actually took a good couple of hours to finish including drafts and scrapped versions, and if you zoom in, that shading is pixel-precise

also the art portal is gay and I don't care what I shit into it so $

[nazi slayer]

Pretty damn nice

I gotta say this is one of the best things I've seen on the front page. Anyway I gave it a 9 instead of a 10 because it's weird how the Nazi is popping chunks as if he's being shot, however the gun doesn't have any flash and the Russian isn't showing any recoil. While this is an awesome piece, it's very important to use realism when painting guns.

Also to snello, hating nazis is only promoting hate, and "giving power" to the Jews is only empowering bigotry.

dommi-fresh responds:

ah you are wise.
i was thinking of doing the muzzel flash and the lighting kinda shows that a little bit but then i realised the flash would take away alot of the detail in the gun and the gore.
and whats better
guns and gore
or a lil flashy washey?
besides without the muzzel flash it leaves it more open to your own interpretation maybe he has just stopped shooting or maybe it is just about to fire another round in the nazi's skull. who knows you decide.
still thanks for writing.

[Elemental Wind]

I hate furries

And I really wanted to give you an unfairly low score, but this was wonderful. How do their pants tuck into their shoes when their shoes are so tiny?

Afterhumanity responds:

I appretiate that guy, Furries arn't all bad just to have an open mind and go with it. I'm happy you enjoyed it.

[Birds and Balloons]

DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUH

DWIZZA WEEA DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN

darthduba responds:

Thanks, I'll take the advice

[Fruit]

Just a heart

I mean, yea it look pretty and all. But it's just a heart.

FatKidWitAJetPak responds:

Its love, beauty, darkness, lust, red, black, hope, dreams, sex, terror, murder, rape, space, sky, wind, power, faith, and many more. Its not JUST a heart. Its whatever you want it to be. It could be JUST a heart, but if its pretty then isnt that good enough? This is deeper than you think. All interpretations are open of course but.. a 3 because its just a heart... seriously? Well thanks for your feedback though, its appreciated.