Smidly's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[John is fat!]

this is a song

it is made of fail and shit.

fizzypop2 responds:

Well, you have the right to your own opinion but I'd like to give you a quote from the author's comments: "This isn't up here to get popular reviews or anything special like that. I just hope it makes someone out there laugh."

[Primecrime Television]

Nothing but noise

It has the smallest bit of coherance and is way too loud. If was somehow cool sounding, despite being random I would like it.

But this really sucks

MadCow responds:

You're just too ignorant to understand. May I recommend "Crimetime Television" for you, it has more obvious Pop-Punk and Alternative Grassroots Jam band influences and mayhaps your miniscule brain will be able to commence preparations for beginning to start understanding the subliminal messages.

[JwM]

good

Title should be prick though.

Playmupp responds:

Thanks for the review. What was/is wrong with the title, I don't understand:P.

[Yarr! Walk the plank(DKC)]

Good yet lacking

I think covers should add onto the original or be it's own song, and it mostly just felt like MIDIs with one guitarline ontop. Perhaps some improvisation

Darkmoor responds:

actually. the only part I used midi is the intro. Just couldnt get the part right. But the rest is all mine. Tried to get it close to the original cuz I think its good enough in itself. Very hard to improve any further. But hey, it might come a V.2

[K-Dm - This Isn't Goodbye]

Great!

Title really fits and overall was great! The guitar was a bit squeallly though.

K-Dm responds:

hmmm ill try to mix the guitar a little better next time

thx for the review

K-Dm

[Photo of rock]

Pretty nice

But I didnt like the pan. It shouldnt stay on one side for that long. Maybe if it was smoother or more sudden it would work. Good job though!

photosyntesen responds:

thank you :)

[I'm Gonna Kill Santa Claus]

meh

Alright guitar and drums, but vocals sucked both in lyrics and quality.

giftedbuttwisted responds:

Eh, ya either love it or hate it XP

[[VN]-A Warm Place]

Alright

I guess it's pretty good but you didnt really capture the feeling of the original. P

VNStudios responds:

I don't think anything can beat the original, but we can try right? Thanks for the review!

~VNSTUDIOS~

[Song of Sacrilege]

Your...god...sucks...cocks

That was fucking hilarious. At first with the author comments I thought you'd be trying to be serious but that was really funny.

Mysterieux responds:

Thank you very much. Glad you enjoyed it. =]