Smidly's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[John is fat!]

this is a song

it is made of fail and shit.

fizzypop2 responds:

Well, you have the right to your own opinion but I'd like to give you a quote from the author's comments: "This isn't up here to get popular reviews or anything special like that. I just hope it makes someone out there laugh."

[Primecrime Television]

Nothing but noise

It has the smallest bit of coherance and is way too loud. If was somehow cool sounding, despite being random I would like it.

But this really sucks

MadCow responds:

You're just too ignorant to understand. May I recommend "Crimetime Television" for you, it has more obvious Pop-Punk and Alternative Grassroots Jam band influences and mayhaps your miniscule brain will be able to commence preparations for beginning to start understanding the subliminal messages.

[JwM]

good

Title should be prick though.

Playmupp responds:

Thanks for the review. What was/is wrong with the title, I don't understand:P.

[Yarr! Walk the plank(DKC)]

Good yet lacking

I think covers should add onto the original or be it's own song, and it mostly just felt like MIDIs with one guitarline ontop. Perhaps some improvisation

Darkmoor responds:

actually. the only part I used midi is the intro. Just couldnt get the part right. But the rest is all mine. Tried to get it close to the original cuz I think its good enough in itself. Very hard to improve any further. But hey, it might come a V.2

[K-Dm - This Isn't Goodbye]

Great!

Title really fits and overall was great! The guitar was a bit squeallly though.

K-Dm responds:

hmmm ill try to mix the guitar a little better next time

thx for the review

K-Dm

[Photo of rock]

Pretty nice

But I didnt like the pan. It shouldnt stay on one side for that long. Maybe if it was smoother or more sudden it would work. Good job though!

photosyntesen responds:

thank you :)

[I'm Gonna Kill Santa Claus]

meh

Alright guitar and drums, but vocals sucked both in lyrics and quality.

giftedbuttwisted responds:

Eh, ya either love it or hate it XP

[[VN]-A Warm Place]

Alright

I guess it's pretty good but you didnt really capture the feeling of the original. P

VNStudios responds:

I don't think anything can beat the original, but we can try right? Thanks for the review!

~VNSTUDIOS~

[Song of Sacrilege]

Your...god...sucks...cocks

That was fucking hilarious. At first with the author comments I thought you'd be trying to be serious but that was really funny.

Mysterieux responds:

Thank you very much. Glad you enjoyed it. =]

[Carol of the Bells (DAMN)]

Was a bit off tempo and repetitive

You sort of repeated the same part of the song too long, and didnt break into the DUN DUH DUH DUH DUH DUH DUUUH DUH DUHDUH DUN DUH DUH DUN DUN untill about 1:30.

I did like what was good though.

Pure-Metal-UTA responds:

Thanks for the input, I know how I can make it better now Songwise, I was looking to see how I was doing soundwise on it however.
As for the tempo, I'm sort of thinking you're talking about the beginning part, and that's because the bass started lagging when I was exporting it (the exporting from GP is really fucked up) so it resulted in some off tempo beats, which I'll fix Next year when I do this.
But thanks!